|
|
Post by penguinsgm on Oct 11, 2010 19:29:49 GMT -5
To Pittsburgh: Mike Knuble, Mike Green, Tomas Fleischmann, Brooks Laich, Karl Alzner, 2nd
To Washington: Brooks Orpik, Evgeni Malkin, 1st
|
|
|
|
Post by capsgm on Oct 11, 2010 19:31:51 GMT -5
Confirm losing green alzner Knuble and laich was tough but we feel like getting malkin will improve our team
|
|
|
|
Post by 98monkeyboy98 on Oct 11, 2010 19:58:23 GMT -5
This is shocking seeing no one go back for malkin except green
A fair trade would of been
Backstrom + Green + 1st
For Malkin
|
|
|
|
Post by capsgm on Oct 11, 2010 20:03:22 GMT -5
whatevery monkeyboy im not listing to what your offering since you make some horrible offers
|
|
|
|
Post by penguinsgm on Oct 11, 2010 21:12:51 GMT -5
This is shocking seeing no one go back for malkin except green A fair trade would of been Backstrom + Green + 1st For Malkin Fleischmann and Laich aren't nobodies...neither is Alzner or Knuble |
|
|
|
Post by starsGM on Oct 12, 2010 13:48:11 GMT -5
This is shocking seeing no one go back for malkin except green A fair trade would of been Backstrom + Green + 1st For Malkin I respectfully disagree. Backstrom himself will put up nearly as much points as Malkin. Let alone Green on top of that. I think the deal is ok but Orpik tilts the trade. Malkin+1st or so for Green, Alzner, Knuble, Flash, Laich. |
|
|
|
Post by ROFLCOPTER (DET) on Oct 12, 2010 17:47:55 GMT -5
Wash may have given up a lot, but it's Malkin... MALKIN!!!! AND a first.
The only problem is wash now is back at lacking in the D department from losing Alzner.
Knuble's gone soon anyway.
|
|
|
|
Post by capsgm on Oct 12, 2010 17:49:06 GMT -5
Wash may have given up a lot, but it's Malkin... MALKIN!!!! AND a first. The only problem is wash now is back at lacking in the D department from losing Alzner. Knuble's gone soon anyway. i prefer carlson to alzner personally |
|
|
|
Post by ROFLCOPTER (DET) on Oct 12, 2010 17:50:37 GMT -5
Wash may have given up a lot, but it's Malkin... MALKIN!!!! AND a first. The only problem is wash now is back at lacking in the D department from losing Alzner. Knuble's gone soon anyway. i prefer carlson to alzner personally Same. But Wash isn't exactly deep at defense. |
|
|
|
Post by capsgm on Oct 12, 2010 17:51:19 GMT -5
ya i no
|
|
|
|
Post by penguinsgm on Oct 12, 2010 17:52:03 GMT -5
Wash may have given up a lot, but it's Malkin... MALKIN!!!! AND a first. The only problem is wash now is back at lacking in the D department from losing Alzner. Knuble's gone soon anyway. trading Malkin for depth up front is a good idea, also my defense is stacked. the first would be bottom 5 where the 2011 class is weak. |
|
|
|
Post by Ducks GM on Oct 13, 2010 9:11:47 GMT -5
This trade basically comes down to Orpik for Alzner, which still might not be enough...and a 2nd, Green, Flash, a 40 yr old, Laich for Malkin AND a 1st?  Terrible when you put it in perspective. The only way Malkin would be dealt is for a star winger+ or franchise D like Doughty or Weber. Green is not there but lets say he is, it wouldn't be done at that expense. Now consider the fact Penguins have similar D in Goli, Letang, Martin and Michalek, this trade is full of fail for the Pens imo. Caps make out like bandits considering they have Carlsson on D as well. Malkin+Backstrom as your top 2 centres and not to mention someone by the name of Ovie on the wing. Semin ain't too shabby either. |
|
|
|
Post by ROFLCOPTER (DET) on Oct 13, 2010 9:42:47 GMT -5
See everyone has a different take on it, so it can't be THAT one-sided.
|
|
|
|
Post by penguinsgm on Oct 13, 2010 20:22:43 GMT -5
This trade basically comes down to Orpik for Alzner, which still might not be enough...and a 2nd, Green, Flash, a 40 yr old, Laich for Malkin AND a 1st? Terrible when you put it in perspective. The only way Malkin would be dealt is for a star winger+ or franchise D like Doughty or Weber. Green is not there but lets say he is, it wouldn't be done at that expense. Now consider the fact Penguins have similar D in Goli, Letang, Martin and Michalek, this trade is full of fail for the Pens imo. Caps make out like bandits considering they have Carlsson on D as well. Malkin+Backstrom as your top 2 centres and not to mention someone by the name of Ovie on the wing. Semin ain't too shabby either. Green, Flash, Laich, and that 40 year old will put up more points than Malkin will. The 1st will be a bottom 5 in the worst draft in the last 10 years, and Alzner will be better than Orpik. |
|
|
|
Post by ROFLCOPTER (DET) on Oct 15, 2010 13:50:30 GMT -5
Not to mention Green is a top-5 d-man in the NHL which in my book is a little more valued than a top-5 forward in the NHL, and at less cap hit.
I don't think Alzner will be better than Orpik, but pens does so i guess they just negate eachother.
|
|
